"Crit surfing" is a sport that writers and other creative types engage in. It does not build any muscles (unless a clenched neck is a desirable physical attribute). It builds maneuvering ability, though, and a taste for intellectual dominance.
I'm working with a college. They need a case written for their $150-or-so million campaign.
The college president more or less approved the case I wrote (with edits) and is hanging semi-tough. The academic who feels most ignored by the process is complaining. The development officer who rooted for me as some kind of magical national expert is embarrassed. I responsed to her extended apology in an email:
This is going exactly as I'd hoped and planned, [insert name here]. Not in the puppet-master sense. In the cattle-drover sense.
Academic environments are predictable, as are their behaviors; in the same way that dating is predictable, kindergartens are predictable, and cattle. (I think that about covers the emotional range.)